Most key performance indicators are designed for the wrong audience. They are built to be reported upward, assembled so that a department head has something to present in the quarterly review, and the people whose work they describe encounter them twice a year: once when the targets are handed down, and once when they are used to justify a rating.
A number that exists to be reported is a measurement. A number a team checks on a Tuesday because it tells them how the week is going is something else entirely.
The difference matters because measurement changes behavior whether or not anyone intends it to. Set average handling time as the metric in a call center and calls get shorter, though not necessarily better.
Reward the number of client meetings booked and meetings get booked, including the ones that were never going to lead anywhere.
Economists call this Goodhart’s law: once a measure becomes a target, it stops being a reliable measure. Managers tend to discover it the slow way, by watching a team hit every indicator in a quarter during which almost nothing improved.
The indicators that motivate have a few things in common. The first is control. If a target depends mostly on factors a person cannot influence, such as a market, a central pricing decision or another department’s backlog, the rational response is resignation rather than effort. Targets should sit close enough to the work that somebody can change the outcome by changing what they do.
The second is restraint. A scorecard with twenty-two indicators communicates that everything is a priority, which means nothing is. Five or six, chosen deliberately and traceable to a departmental objective, tell a team where to put its attention when the week gets busy. Anything else can be tracked without being a target.
The third is authorship. Targets written with a team land very differently from targets written for one, and the usual objection, that people will set the bar low, rarely survives contact with reality.
Employees asked to propose their own indicators tend to be harder on themselves than their managers would have been, and they can also say which measures are unfair before the year begins rather than during the appraisal.
The fourth is rhythm. Indicators reviewed once a year are a verdict. Indicators reviewed monthly are a conversation, and the conversation is where the improvement happens. It also helps to balance lagging measures, which report what already happened, with leading ones that a team can act on now.
None of this removes the need for honest judgment about underperformance. It simply means the numbers are doing some of the work rather than arriving at the end as a surprise.
Spearhead Training runs Performance and KPI Management on 7 and 8 December. The two-day program treats KPIs as a compass for managers, covering performance management systems, setting meaningful indicators linked to departmental objectives, conducting appraisals and carrying out a training needs analysis. It is built for managers and leaders responsible for the performance of others.
Next Steps
Explore the full Spearhead Training course portfolio and for immediate questions, contact Spearhead Training at 04 3362552.